The Detroit Tigers are 44-52, six and a half games out of a playoff spot they do not currently occupy, and their best pitcher has spent the last week publicly campaigning for them to buy at the trade deadline. Tarik Skubal, two-time AL Cy Young winner and baseball’s most coveted rental property, would like you to know that the Tigers are, actually, very good.
“Hopefully the decision-makers see that we’re a very good team and it’s not sell at the deadline — it’s add,” Skubal said on July 10. “I think we’re a really good team, and there are so many guys in this room that have proven that we can go on a run as we did in ‘24.”
This is an objectively reasonable thing to believe about a team that went on a legitimate run in 2024. It is also a thing being said by a man who becomes a free agent in November, who is represented by Scott Boras, and who is seeking what Boras will describe as the largest pitching contract in baseball history. The Tigers cannot afford to sign him. They are already quietly trading fringe relievers for cash. Tarik Skubal is cheerleading for a team that has one foot out the door, and he either doesn’t know it or has decided it’s not worth thinking about.
https://x.com/UnderdogMLB/status/2076300872984801404
The situation everyone else is actually in: contenders have been circling since June. Houston confirmed; others lurking. The problem is pricing. Skubal walks in November regardless of where he pitches the next six weeks, which means any team that trades for him is paying franchise-caliber prospect prices for approximately two months of a starting pitcher — and then watching him walk into the Boras free agency machine anyway. You could wait, sign him in the offseason, and keep your prospects intact; this is not an irrational thing to do. It is, however, exactly the kind of calculation that produces trade deadline standoffs, where everyone agrees a player is extraordinary and nobody agrees he’s worth what it costs to get him.
Detroit’s position is the most uncomfortable one. They need a top-of-the-rotation return to move a two-time Cy Young winner, because anything less looks like a fire sale — and the optics of a fire sale would confirm exactly what Skubal is out there publicly denying. But contenders aren’t going to pay that price for a rental, which means the Tigers are asking for more than the market will bear, which means they are probably not trading him, which means Skubal gets his wish by default, and the Tigers finish 2026 wherever the math says they finish. That’s not a negotiating strategy so much as a situation that has arranged itself around everyone’s inability to move.
The counterargument is that teams panic at deadlines; someone will overpay. It has happened before. The MLB trade deadline is a reliable generator of decisions that look insane in October. Maybe an Astros executive blinks on a Tuesday night in late July and decides two months of Skubal is worth what Detroit should demand in return. It’s possible.
It’s also possible that Skubal keeps pitching for a fourth-place team, posts a 2.90 ERA, and hits free agency in November as the most expensive pitcher on the market, at which point Detroit will have to explain why they didn’t trade him. They will say they believed in the team. The team will finish under .500. Skubal will sign somewhere for $350 million. Everyone will move on.
The Tigers are doing seller activity (cash trades, roster clearing) while their ace holds press conferences about the postseason. At some point, one of these things is going to have to give. The deadline is August 1. Nobody’s blinking yet; the question is just who runs out of patience first, and whether it matters either way.
