The Knicks are up 2-0 in the Eastern Conference Finals and I genuinely cannot explain what I’m watching except to say that Harden’s defense is the crime scene and everybody already knows it.
Game 1 was a 22-point fourth-quarter collapse — one of exactly two times in NBA playoff history that a team has blown that kind of lead that late, per ESPN’s breakdown of the pick coverage. Teams up 22+ in the fourth quarter of playoff games were 594-1 before this series. The Cavs are now the second entry on that list. Congratulations, I guess.
https://twitter.com/NBA/status/2056929956161016192
Here’s what actually happened: the Knicks ran pick-and-roll at Harden 27 times in Game 1, a career-high for on-ball pick coverage. They scored 1.6 points per possession on those actions. When Brunson specifically found Harden on a switch, it went to 1.80 PPP. That’s not a defensive scheme. That’s an invitation. Jalen Brunson had 15 points in the fourth quarter alone on 7-of-9 shooting and then somehow scored zero in overtime because he was already done working.
Mike Brown, the Knicks coach, put it with the subtlety of a freight train: “It was no secret. We were attacking Harden.”
You love to hear that. You love to hear a coach say out loud, to the press, with no apology, that they spent two weeks drawing up a plan to hunt a specific 36-year-old man every time he stepped on the floor. That’s not a game plan, that’s a hunting license.
Game 2 was somehow worse. Harden shot 6-of-15 and the Cavs were outscored by 22 points in his 32 minutes. Josh Hart — Josh Hart! — dropped a playoff career-high 26 points. Brunson went for 19 and 14 assists and barely broke a sweat doing it. The Cavaliers lost by 16.
Donovan Mitchell had 29 points and 6 steals in Game 1. He had 26 in Game 2. Mitchell is doing absolutely everything right and it doesn’t matter because his defense is being set on fire by a guy who is actively inviting contact at every pick. Mitchell’s prime is burning in real time and the culprit is a roster decision Cleveland made in the offseason.
The Cavs coach Kenny Atkinson defended Harden after Game 2, telling reporters that Harden is a “good isolation defender” and that it never crossed his mind to pull out Harden. He also said micro experiences get exaggerated. The internet did not receive this warmly. Kendrick Perkins called Harden a “defensive liability” on ESPN, which felt less like analysis and more like the rest of us just saying it on TV.
Game 3 is tonight at 8 PM ET in Cleveland at Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse. The Cavs need a win or this is basically over — no team in NBA history has ever come back from 0-3. The crowd will be loud, the desperation will be real, and Jalen Brunson will spend the fourth quarter finding James Harden on every screen like he’s doing a scavenger hunt he already memorized.
Cleveland brought Harden in for veteran playmaking. He’s played two playoff games and given up 85 combined points in his minutes. That’s the deal they made.
